LETTERS: MLA Barnett is forgetting the constitution

This letter is a response to the January 16 “MLA Musings” piece

Editor:

This letter is a response to the January 16 “MLA Musings” piece in the Williams Lake Tribune. Notwithstanding the provincial government’s handling of the Wet’suwet’en pipeline blockade earlier this month, I take issue with MLA Donna Barnett’s characterization of the illegality of the Indigenous activists’ blockade of the natural gas pipeline in B.C.’s northwest. The protests may challenge a recent provincial court ruling but they are not unconstitutional. After all, the Charter guarantees the freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly.

The BC Supreme Court ruling may have the impact of allowing the Coastal GasLink pipeline to move forward from a provincial perspective, but its failure to account for the consequences of the Supreme Court of Canada ruling, specifically the Delgamuukw v British Columbia SCC case (1997), justifies reasonable opposition. Delgamuukw established the authority of the hereditary chiefs in the Nation’s unceded territory. As legal scholar John Burrows has argued, these cases of Indigenous sovereignty, rooted in natural law, are essential parts of Canada’s legal and judicial fabric, creating our composite constitution.

READ MORE: A government of activists

The work of anthropologist Antonia Mills further corroborates the importance of the hereditary chiefs of the Wet’suwet’en as both legislative and judicial authorities in the Nation. Considering that the company planned infrastructure development on unceded lands, settler authorities would do well to consult with traditional Indigenous authorities in addition to the Indian Act band councils. As Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, President of the Union of BC Indian Chiefs, has argued, band councils may have an electoral system behind them, but that does not derogate the need for free, prior, and informed consent from traditional Indigenous government representatives.

To suggest that activists’ constitutionally-guaranteed freedoms are contrary to the “rule of law” and the “economic progress of our province” is unadulterated sophistry. Who decided that those phrases meant blindly embracing without question an environmentally and financially questionable infrastructure project? We live in interesting times. Let’s not make them more interesting by forgetting the constitution, the supreme law of the land.

Joe Borsato

Williams Lake

Just Posted

Almost $1 million in BC Rural Dividend funds awarded in Cariboo region

Funds awarded to support economic development and diversification in rural communities

VIDEO: Weber gives gold medal performance at Special Olympics speaking engagement

“If we have the coaches I think you will get the athletes, too,” he said.

BC Ferries confirms Northern Sea Wolf ready for summer season

The plan is to have the Northern Sea Wolf assume the mid-coast service as of May 18

LETTER: Controlling the wolf population does make a difference

These are my experiences in the Itcha Ilgatchuz Park region as a third generation rancher, mountain trail riding guide/packer and big game guide outfitter

Williams Lake RCMP raise awareness for Auto Crime Enforcement Month

April 2019 is Auto Crime Enforcement Month, and the RCMP are asking the public to stay alert.

Sri Lanka invokes war-time military powers after nearly 300 killed in Easter bombings

Sri Lanka’s minister of tourism says 39 foreign tourists were killed in the Easter Sunday attacks

Northern B.C. yoga studio raises $2,500 for woman leaving abusive relationship

The 100 Mile House studio held a fundraiser yoga class and accepted donations from members to help the woman

Ex-mayor of northern village claims its drivers are overpaying ICBC $1,800 a year

Darcy Repen says data shows Telkwa households are being ripped off for car insurance

Deadly synthetic drug found in Kamloops that puts users in ‘zombielike’ state

Interior Health warning says substance causes ‘speedy, trippy-like symptoms’ and hallucinations

Trudeau to be portrayed on ‘Simpsons’ episode

Toronto journalist who’s posted videos of himself doing impressions of the PM voiced him for the show

Elizabeth May’s wedding dress a ‘walk through a garden’ on Earth Day

Green Party leader set to get married in Victoria

Bodies of 3 mountain climbers recovered after last week’s Banff avalanche

The men disappeared while attempting to climb the east face of Howse Peak in the Icefields Parkway

Happy birthday: Queen Elizabeth II turns 93 on Easter Sunday

Sunday is the first of two birthday celebrations each year for the queen

RCMP confirm witnesses say body found at Kelowna’s Gyro Beach

Police tape is blocking part of the beach and several RCMP officers are on scene.

Most Read