LETTERS: MLA Barnett is forgetting the constitution

This letter is a response to the January 16 “MLA Musings” piece


This letter is a response to the January 16 “MLA Musings” piece in the Williams Lake Tribune. Notwithstanding the provincial government’s handling of the Wet’suwet’en pipeline blockade earlier this month, I take issue with MLA Donna Barnett’s characterization of the illegality of the Indigenous activists’ blockade of the natural gas pipeline in B.C.’s northwest. The protests may challenge a recent provincial court ruling but they are not unconstitutional. After all, the Charter guarantees the freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly.

The BC Supreme Court ruling may have the impact of allowing the Coastal GasLink pipeline to move forward from a provincial perspective, but its failure to account for the consequences of the Supreme Court of Canada ruling, specifically the Delgamuukw v British Columbia SCC case (1997), justifies reasonable opposition. Delgamuukw established the authority of the hereditary chiefs in the Nation’s unceded territory. As legal scholar John Burrows has argued, these cases of Indigenous sovereignty, rooted in natural law, are essential parts of Canada’s legal and judicial fabric, creating our composite constitution.

READ MORE: A government of activists

The work of anthropologist Antonia Mills further corroborates the importance of the hereditary chiefs of the Wet’suwet’en as both legislative and judicial authorities in the Nation. Considering that the company planned infrastructure development on unceded lands, settler authorities would do well to consult with traditional Indigenous authorities in addition to the Indian Act band councils. As Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, President of the Union of BC Indian Chiefs, has argued, band councils may have an electoral system behind them, but that does not derogate the need for free, prior, and informed consent from traditional Indigenous government representatives.

To suggest that activists’ constitutionally-guaranteed freedoms are contrary to the “rule of law” and the “economic progress of our province” is unadulterated sophistry. Who decided that those phrases meant blindly embracing without question an environmentally and financially questionable infrastructure project? We live in interesting times. Let’s not make them more interesting by forgetting the constitution, the supreme law of the land.

Joe Borsato

Williams Lake

Just Posted

Williams Lake considering one per cent tax increase

If approved the one per cent extra tax funds would go toward asphalt recycling

Williams Lake warming up following record snowfall

Williams Lake is digging out from 13 centimetres of fresh snowfall

Station House Gallery: Making Faces invites viewers to take themselves less seriously

“Some people find the exhibit hilarious and others find it disturbing.”

Torch passed for Nature Kids program at Scout Island

Paula Laita is passing the Nature Kids baton on to Bill Gilroy and Kim Zalay.

‘Riya was a dreamer’: Mother of slain 11-year-old Ontario girl heartbroken

Her father, Roopesh Rajkumar, 41, was arrested some 130 kilometres away

Experts urge caution after 10 human-triggered avalanches across B.C.

One man is still stuck after avalanche on south coast

‘It consumed my life’: Inside the world of gaming addiction

World Health Organization classifies gaming disorder as a mental health condition

Police seize bottles of grapefruit vodka from wanted man’s snow-pants

The men were pushing two shopping carts with a woman inside

Tonight’s sporting event costs more than the Super Bowl, and Obama is going

Tickets are going for more than $4,000 to watch the Duke - North Carolina basketball game

CRTC report finds ‘misleading, aggressive’ sales tactics used by telecom industry

Report recommends measures to make a fairer situation for consumers

Trudeau takes personal hit amid SNC-Lavalin controversy: poll

Overall, 41 per cent of respondents believed the prime minister had done something wrong in the affair

B.C. photographer captures otters on ice

A Langley photographer was at the right place at the right time on the Fraser River

Do you live with your partner? More and more Canadians don’t

Statistics Canada shows fewer couples live together than did a decade ago

Most Read