COLUMNS: Big cow, little cow – does size really matter?

There have been a lot of studies trying to calculate whether the size of a mother cow makes a difference.

There have been a lot of studies trying to calculate whether the size of a mother cow makes a difference to the profitability of the ranch operation.

From my reading it seems that the bigger the cow, the smaller the relative size of the calf.  Conversely a smaller cow weans a calf, which is relatively bigger as a percentage of the mother’s size, than the calves of the bigger cows.

Larger cows wean more pounds each, but running more, smaller cows, on the same amount of land probably means more pounds of calves.

They may be smaller calves but then the price per pound of smaller calves has been higher.

One measure is how many pounds of calves are weaned and ready for sale on the same land and feed base as the larger cows. Then you have to account for the higher price for the smaller calves.

On open range a cow unit (Animal unit Month, AUM)  is based on a 1000 pound cow, but you can run 1,300 to 1,400-pound cows and pay the roughly $3 per AUM. But once on private pasture or your own hay this advantage is not there.

It is cheaper to run the larger cows on open range than it is the smaller ones. So this needs to be taken into account. But pasture rates are not the big item.

Private pasture costs about $15-30 per animal per month, usually closer to $18.

So, over six months, it might cost $70 more on private land to keep that cow on private versus the public pasture.

Bigger cows are economically more efficient during the summer pasturing time because they bring in more pounds of calves at a lower cost.

But something like 60 per cent of the cost of keeping a cow is in the winter feeding, so the real test is what is the profit per acre of land or per pound of feed.

Here is where the smaller cows appear to shine.

While some studies say larger cows are more efficient at feed conversion. Most studies say the opposite.

One recent study at the University of Wyoming shows the big cow ranch (similar to B.C.s average size) had a four year average of $139,000 gross income, whereas the small cow ranch produced $173,000.

Another study from Auburn University concluded: “the cost of the extra feed required maintaining the heavier cows for a year will not be offset by the additional pounds of calf produced and their market value.”

Conclusion from the Auburn study: “Don’t let your cows get too large. Smaller cows are more efficient with their feed usage than larger cows.”

There needs to more data from operations here so we know our facts but research from away points to needing smaller cows but more of them on the same land base is the way to go.

The real consideration is what is the cost per pound on your operation.  Calculation input costs and depreciation on the cows is also important. Some suggest smaller cows live longer and produce more calves over their lifetime.

Others may differ in their opinion. Perhaps the secret to success is to find cows from your own place or from somewhere else that fit your particular environment.

David Zirnhelt is a member of the Cariboo Cattlemen’s Association and chair of the advisory committee for the Applied Sustainable Ranching program which started at Thompson Rivers University in Williams Lake this January.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

New cargo van for Williams Lake Salvation Army

Walmart Foundation helps fund purchase

BC Supreme Court hears how Williams Lake arrest leads to addict’s recovery

“I would also like to apologize for any harm I may have done”

BC VOTES 2020: Provincial election will have familiar duo battling in Cariboo North

The two candidates who received the most votes in 2017 will both be running in Cariboo North again

Nine new COVID-19 cases announced in Interior Health region

The total number of cases since the pandemic started is now at 531 for the region

B.C.’s top doctor encourages Halloween costumes to include masks

Dr. Bonnie Henry will soon be releasing guidelines on how to safely trick-or-treat this Halloween

B.C. VOTES 2020: Few solutions offered for ‘out of control’ camping

B.C. Liberals, NDP spend millions as problem keeps growing

Federal child-care plan could help Canada rebound from COVID-induced economic crisis: prof

A $2 billion investment this year could help parents during second wave of pandemic

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Action demanded over death of First Nations youth in Abbotsford group home

Family and Indigenous organizations push for thorough investigation

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

B.C. nurses report rise in depression, anxiety, exhaustion due to pandemic

A new UBC study looks into how the COVID-19 response has impacted frontline nurses

Horgan frustrated as Transport Canada mandate for BC Ferry riders returns

Transport Canada reinstates rule that bans passengers from lower decks

Reincarnation, baby! Music-making B.C. couple celebrate ‘miracle’ pregnancy

‘I (said) to Adam, ‘I really think this is your brother reincarnated,’ Elise Estrada says

Most Read