COLUMN: ‘Researchers conclude livestock have no detectable effect on climate‘

Let’s not throw the baby out with the bathwater

Researchers conclude livestock have no detectable effect on climate.

This conclusion should say “Methane Emissions from Livestock Have No Detectable Effect on The Climate.

When I see a headline in a news article, I try to check out the original research that spawns the headline. In this case, the article is in Climate Change Dispatch, back in 2018, quoting the abstract from a research paper by Dr. Albrecht Glatzle.

He concludes, “there is no scientific evidence, whatsoever, that domestic livestock could represent a risk for the Earth’s climate” and, “the warming potential of anthropogenic (people caused) GHG emissions has been exaggerated.”

The evidence he provides is that his team “could not find a clear domestic livestock fingerprint, neither in the geographical methane distribution nor in the historical evolution of mean atmospheric methane concentration.”

To offer some evidence of proof of this argument, Glatzle states that from 1990 to 2005 the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) say that there was a complete stabilization of atmospheric methane, despite the world cattle population increasing by one million head.

Read More: RANCH MUSINGS: We are at the mercy of the weather

On the other hand, the argument goes that livestock are important in keeping the two thirds of the world’s agricultural land (grazing and grasslands) producing food.

Yes, adding another billion people is not good, and it is the demand by humans for resource consumption that is, in my view, the biggest climate challenge.

That said, our collective challenge is to convert degraded farmland on a “regenerative” path, not just a “sustainable” path.

Cattle eat much of the byproduct of human food like grain and pulses (peas and other legumes)—straw from these foods, which humans can’t consume.

This information comes from a paper by Taro Takahashi presented at the international Alltech conference in Lexington, Kentucky, this spring. He hails from an English Institute which has been studying pasture soil since 1856.

He argues that manure is an important part of any sustainable arable farming system.

Read More: Why we do what we do

Further he says that if you have a higher stocking rate and uniform distribution of animals, the soil health and structure is vastly improved.

I guess one of my conclusions is that we shouldn’t be plowing up any more of the marginal soils to try to raise human or animal food that way. Ruminants evolved to digest course plant-based food.

This is a case of not throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Advocates for plant-based protein for human food, need to be careful in assuming that stopping eating meat is good for the planet.

Maybe the science they are using to back their claims is faulty. But then too, livestock producers need to up their game and focus on soil health because more soil organic matter will increase the water holding capacity and therefore grow more and better feed, more efficiently.

High fossil fuel users are still the big emitters, while beef producers as fossil fuel users consume only about 0.7 per cent.

The study from Britain “suggest(s) that each individual beef sector and the entire value chain can produce more high quality protein than is consumed in production.”

Do you have a comment about this story? email:

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

David Zirnhelt is a rancher and member of the Cariboo Cattlemen’s Association. He is also chair of the Advisory Committee for the Applied Sustainable Ranching Program at TRU.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Editorial: Have your say on changes to assisted dying law

In June of 2016 Canadians gained the right to physician assisted death — but there were caveats

Kind-hearted road worker takes home discarded bin of pet rats at Highway 20 rest stop

Maddy McCarthy said she will find the nine pets loving homes

Horsefly community hosts party celebrating skating rink grand opening

The community of Horsefly hosted a party celebrating the opening of its new, outdoor skating rink

Reported ‘armed and barricaded’ male safely apprehended by 100 Mile RCMP

The male was taken to the local hospital for further assessment by a physician

VIDEO: Canada’s first presumptive case of coronavirus officially confirmed

Both patient and wife arrived on a China Southern Airlines flight after having been to Wuhan

First-place Canucks beat Blues 3-1 for ninth straight home win

Miller nets pair as Vancouver defeats Cup champs

Swapping grape varieties can help winemakers adapt to climate change: UBC study

Report says 56% of wine-grape-growing regions would be lost if global climate warms by 2 C

Alberta premier wants feds to approve Teck mine for benefit of First Nations

Kenney: ‘Surely [reconciliation] means saying yes to economic development for First Nations people’

Police search for man who went missing from Vernon hotel

Jay Rosenberger, 38, was last seen Friday

NDP suggests easing secondary housing rules for B.C. farmland

Lana Popham proposes guest homes not just for relatives

After four sexual assaults in the same B.C. park, RCMP ask women not to walk alone

Four sexual assaults took place in Glen Park over two months

BC Place lights up in purple and yellow to honour Kobe Bryant

Kobe Bryant, his 13-year-old daughter and seven others were killed in a helicopter crash

Whistleblower says Iranian-Americans questioned at Peace Arch crossing were targeted

Immigration lawyer says response from Customs Border Protection is a ‘total cover up’

Most Read