WLIB taking appeal decision to Supreme Court of Canada

WLIB going to Supreme Court of Canada after its Specific Claims Tribunal ruling has been overturned by the Federal Court of Appeal.

  • Mar. 10, 2016 6:00 p.m.

Williams Lake Indian Band has decided go to Canada’s highest court to contest the Federal Court of Appeal’s recent decision to overturn the Specific Claims Tribunal that ruled in the band’s favour in 2014.

“The WLIB, deeply disappointed with Canada’s decision to place yet another barrier in the path to resolution of its legitimate and valid claim, has now confirmed that it will apply for leave to appeal this decision to the Supreme Court of Canada,” the band stated in a press release Thursday.

In 2014, the Specific Claims Tribunal had concluded that the Band had village lands (ie: an “Indian Settlement”) in Williams Lake at the time the Colony of British Columbia was established in 1858, and that the Colony had failed to ensure that the Village Lands were protected for the Band from pre-emption by settlers.

The Tribunal concluded that Canada had become responsible for the Colony’s failure to protect the Band’s village lands and also held that Canada breached its fiduciary obligations when federal officials and reserve commissioners allowed the unlawful pre-emptions to trump the Band’s interests.

Federal officials took no steps to try to acquire the Village Lands from the settlers and instead allotted other lands (“Sugarcane”) as reserves of the Band.

The area in question (“Village Lands”) includes Williams Creek, Scout Island, Williams Lake Stampede Grounds, the city’s downtown core, and a plateau north of the downtown core.

WLIB Chief Ann Louie said the Federal Court of Appeal acted in an unusual and unprecedented fashion by overturning the Specific Claims Tribunal ruling.

“The Court (FCA) approached the judicial review more in the manner of an appeal, which we consider unjust, unfair and unlawful,” Louie said. “Federal legislation stipulates all Tribunal decisions are to be final, binding and not subject to appeal. Despite this, and clear guidelines set out in judicial review provisions, the Federal Court itself even described its rendering of this ‘new decision’ as an appeal.”

Chief Louie said at the time of the judicial review in May 2015 the community was concerned it was being treated like a court of appeal.

“At the time, we felt this was wrong and that it was handled incorrectly, and today our doubts about the process have been realized.”

Louie said the Specific Claims Tribunal Act states that judicial reviews are there to assess whether the judge erred in applying the act itself, not to retry the case.

The Specific Claims Tribunal is a unique independent body of Superior Court justices, which was established in 2008, to rectify Canada’s conflict of interest in adjudicating claims and restore confidence in the integrity of the specific claims process to First Nations.

Tribunal members have the legal and historical expertise to decide complex historical grievances pertaining to Canada’s legal obligations under the Indian Act to protect First Nations lands and assets.

Tribunals do not return lands to First Nations, but instead financially compensate them to a maximum of $150 million.

“Canada must seriously reflect on the paternalistic, overreaching nature and injustice of the Federal Court’s decision,” said Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, president of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs in a press release. “This ruling completely undermines the independence and authority of the Tribunal that Canada established through legislation to restore legitimacy to the specific claims process and in so doing, further erodes First Nations confidence in the process to resolve these grievances.”  Grand Chief Stewart said the substantive historical and legal specific claim issues must be heard by judges with historical knowledge and expertise in Aboriginal law, as intended.

In applying for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, WLIB will contend that the Federal Court altered many of the Tribunal’s findings of fact, based on its own re-weighing of the evidence and without the benefit of expertise in the area of Aboriginal law or land claims, thereby substituting vastly different conclusions based on its own review of the facts of the case, dismissing the Band’s claim on the basis that it received alternate reserve lands as a replacement for their village.


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Lorne Lake, 69, is urging local, provincial and federal governments to find ways to do whatever it takes to make sure smaller cities have the medical help they need. He is currently without a family doctor. (Monica Lamb-Yorski photo - Williams Lake Tribune)
Doctor shortage weighing heavily on Williams Lake senior

Lorne Lake said it is up to the City, provincial and federal governments to find ways to attract doctors

Canadian Mental Health Association Cariboo Chilcotin Branch homeless outreach worker Wayne Lucier said there is no affordable housing presently available in Williams Lake. (Monica Lamb-Yorski photo - Williams Lake Tribune)
Lack of affordable housing concerning for agencies tackling homelessness in Williams Lake

Agencies in town are stretched and our resources are not infinite

Laurel White, Boys and Girls Club of Williams Lake and District harm reduction co-ordinator holds a fentanyl drug testing strip. (Monica Lamb-Yorski photo - Williams Lake Tribune)
Williams Lake drug overdoses triple in September

Total overdose call volume has already surpassed the last few years

Over the years, Janice Blackie-Goodine’s home in Summerland has featured elaborate Halloween displays and decorations each October. (File photo)
QUIZ: How much do you really know about Halloween?

Oct. 31 is a night of frights. How much do you know about Halloween customs and traditions?

FILE - In this Jan. 23, 1987 file photo, actor Sean Connery holds a rose in his hand as he talks about his new movie “The Name of the Rose” at a news conference in London. Scottish actor Sean Connery, considered by many to have been the best James Bond, has died aged 90, according to an announcement from his family. (AP Photo/Gerald Penny, File)
Actor Sean Connery, the ‘original’ James Bond, dies at 90

Oscar-winner was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II in 2000

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Michelle Stoney carved this pumpkin on Wednesday, Oct. 28 at her brother's home where their family gathers each year to carve pumpkins for Halloween. (Michelle Stoney, Gitxsan Artist Facebook photo)
Gitxsan artist carves culture in Halloween pumpkin

Michelle Stoney spent more than three hours on her latest holiday creation

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

This house at 414 Royal Ave. became notorious for its residents’ and visitors’ penchant for attracting police. It was also the site of a gruesome torture in August 2018. It was demolished in 2019. KTW
6-year sentence for Kamloops man who helped carve ‘rat’ into flesh of fellow gang member

Ricky Dennis was one of three men involved in the August 2018 attack

Cpl. Nathan Berze, media officer for the Mission RCMP, giving an update on the investigation at 11:30 a.m., Oct. 30. Patrick Penner photo.
VIDEO: Prisoner convicted of first-degree murder still at large from Mission Institution

When 10 p.m. count was conducted, staff discovered Roderick Muchikekwanape had disappeared

Among the pumpkin carvings created this year by Rick Chong of Abbotsford is this tribute to fallen officer Cont. Allan Young.
Abbotsford pumpkin carver’s creations include fallen police officer

Rick Chong carves and displays 30 pumpkins every year

Most Read