Varying opinions presented at fluoride open house

The debate of whether to fluoridate municipal water supplies is frequently a polarizing one with studies and counter studies on both sides.

The debate of whether to fluoridate municipal water supplies is frequently a polarizing one with studies and counter studies on both sides.

On Thursday evening the City attempted to inject some balance to assist residents in making up their minds on the future of the additive in the city’s water supply in advance of the Nov. 19 referendum on the issue.

Williams Lake dentist Christine Constabel and University of Calgary professor of medical biophysics James Beck were the invited speakers who presented widely divergent views on the issue during the City’s fluoridation open house at the fire hall.

Constabel’s pro-fluoride stance was supported by four other local dentists who wrote a letter to council in early October  indicating their support for the ongoing use of fluoride. The letter stated: “Over 50 years of extensive research through the world has consistently proven how safe and effective fluoride is in the community water supply when it is used appropriately.”

Beck, meanwhile, presented data linking the use of fluoride to harm to some of the body’s functions.

A few members of the City’s water advisory committee that recommended the City explore the issue of municipal fluoridation were also on hand.

John Dressler, chair of the WAC, said when the City asked the committee for a recommendation on fluoridation most members had some opposition to fluoridating on the grounds that it was “unnecessary” due to fluoride occurring naturally in the water system and that the process was costly to the City.

Dressler said there were also doubts about the benefits of fluoridating the water when he said it was questionable how much municipal water the community’s youth actually consumed. Dressler added that with a proportion of the City’s water being used for purposes other than ingestion there wasn’t a benefit to fluoridating.

Beck presented World Health Organization data, noting that the number of decayed, missing and filled teeth in residents had decreased in 18 industrialized countries over a several-decade period: 14 of those countries were not fluoridated and four were.

He presented other data suggesting fluoride could pose potential harm to human teeth, bones, thyroid systems, the reproductive and cardiovascular systems and the brain. Fluoride, said Beck, increases the instances of dental fluorosis which can cause pitting in the tooth enamel leading to cavities.

He indicated it has been tied to decreased thyroid performance and an increase in the occurrence of goiters in fluoridated areas compared to non-fluoridated areas.

He further pointed to data comparing the cities of Montreal, which doesn’t fluoridate, to Toronto that does where the sperm count of men is higher in the former city compared to the latter.

There has also been some studies, said Beck, that suggest a lowering of IQ  in areas that have higher fluoridation.

In response, Constabel discounted those claims saying other than dental fluorosis there are no negative effects of fluoridation.

“I don’t believe it,” she said of the alleged harmful effects of fluoride.

She pointed to data indicating fluoridation results in 20 to 40 per cent fewer cavities in children; that fluoride strengthens the formation of adult teeth in children, remineralizes adult and elderly teeth and strengthens weakened tooth surfaces in the elderly.

“It’s been studied world wide and found to be safe,” she said.

Constabel provided a letter written in September from the Interior Health Authority to the city supporting the practice of fluoridation.

The letter stated “Interior Health supports fluoridation as one of the best practices available in the prevention of dental caries (cavities); IH continues to support the fluoridation of drinking water systems for those communities currently fluoridated; IH encourages the fluoridation of drinking system for those communities without fluoridation.”

Constabel further cited the British Columbia Dental Association, which supports the use of fluoridation as “a safe and effective preventative health measure to reduce tooth decay.”

The City is not currently fluoridating its water supply. On Nov. 19 a referendum asking residents whether they want to restart fluoridation will be held in conjunction with the municipal election. A decision to cease fluoridation must be made either by referendum or ministerial assent.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A 100 Mile RCMP officer stands watch at the intersction of Highway 97 and Horse Lake Road. (Patrick Davies photo - 100 Mile Free Press)
Volunteers, police search Highway 97 for articles related to high-speed chase

Search will stretch from Canco Gas Station in Lac La Hache to 150 Mile House.

An aerial photograph captures snowmobile tracks in the Cameron Ridge area earlier this year, which is closed to snowmobilers. The closures are in place to protect sensitive caribou herds. (Conservation Officer Service photo)
Snowmobilers fined for operating in closed caribou habitat near Likely, B.C.

The investigation revealed they had spent several hours in the closure leaving extensive tracks

The RCMP arrest one of the suspects on Highway 97 courtesy of cell phone footage shot by a bystander. (April Thomas photo)
WATCH: Two suspects arrested after multi-jurisdictional chase

A half dozen police cars were seen heading north on Highway 97

Commercial tenants at the Williams Lake Regional Airport have been granted an additional six-month rent reprieve. (Angie Mindus file photo - Williams Lake Tribune)
Continuing rent relief for Williams Lake Airport tenants considered

City council discussed the option during a committee of the whole meeting

The Grade 2 class of 150 Mile House Elementary attended Cariboo Memorial Hospital with teacher Kirsty Bowers to deliver “kindness” bags full of small gifts to housekeeping staff. (Rebecca Dyok photo)
150 Mile House students deliver gift bags showing appreciation for hospital staff

Students begin Monday morning with a bus trip to Cariboo Memorial Hospital

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

A vial of Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine is pictured at a family doctor office, Thursday, Feb. 25, 2021 in Paris. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP -Christophe Ena
Trudeau ‘optimistic’ that timeline for rollout of COVID vaccines can be accelerated

Canada set to receive more than 6M COVID-19 vaccine dose than initially expected, by end of March

Beginning late Tuesday, anti-pipeline protesters blocked the intersection of Hastings Street and Clark Drive in Vancouver. (Instagram/Braidedwarriors)
Demonstrators block key access to Vancouver port over jail for pipeline protester

They group is protesting a 90-day jail sentence handed to a fellow anti-pipeline protester

Two Vancouver police officers were struck by a car when the driver learned he was being arrested for allegedly using a fraudulent credit card to pay for food. (Vancouver Police Department)
Driver being arrested for alleged food order fraud rams Vancouver police with car

Two officers are in stable condition, suffering with soft tissue injuries following the incident

A discarded blue surgical mask is shown hanging in a bush in Montreal, Sunday, Dec. 6, 2020, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
B.C. RMT suspended for not wearing a mask after confirmed by undercover clients

College of Massage Therapists has 5 open files, said suspension necessary to protect public

A boat caught fire in Ladysmith Harbour on Saturday morning. (Photo submitted)
Missing woman’s remains recovered after Vancouver Island boat fire

Remains of a 60-year-old woman recovered after Feb. 27 boat fire took her life

Most Read