Report compares environmental review processes

A new report from Smithers-based Northwest Institute (NWI) has come down hard on the provincial environmental assessment office’s processes for reviewing proposals, particularly as it related to Taseko Mines’ Prosperity project.

A new report from Smithers-based Northwest Institute (NWI) has come down hard on the provincial environmental assessment office’s processes for reviewing proposals, particularly as it related to Taseko Mines’ Prosperity project.

NWI commissioned the report, written by environmental lawyer Mark Haddock, because the Prosperity environmental review was a unique chance to compare the provincial and federal processes.

“This is the first time in quite a while that there’s been an environmental assessment done by both the provincial and federal governments separately. Normally they have what they call a harmonized process,” said NWI executive director Pat Moss.

The environmental assessment process approved the mine provincially but the federal government’s own review said no to the project.

According to this report, the provincial process leaves much to be desired.

“[Haddock] found that the provincial review was much less thorough, didn’t look at the full range of issues that the federal one did,” Moss said. “Overall there was a sense that it was a much more rushed process.”

Among the highlights of what the report found was that the provincial Environmental Assessment Office (EAO)  dismissed or missed many impacts the federal panel found significant, the EAO did not analyze cumulative effects on grizzly bears, and that the EA lacks clear policies and guidelines in addressing issues such as fish and wildlife.

The report paints a bleak picture, especially when taken together with the recent auditor general’s report that criticized the EAO’s ability to monitor projects after a certificate has been issued.

“The two [reports] coupled together certainly give a sense that we can’t have a lot of confidence that environmental assessment in B.C. is really doing the job it was meant to which is to do a thorough assessment of environmental assessment,” Moss said.

Acting executive director for the EAO, John Mazure, points out that the provincial and federal processes have different mandates but the B.C. process still looks at the big picture.

“If you had a mining project and forestry activity in the same area, if the mining project was coming through our process we’d certainly look at how the impacts of that mine on bears, for example, would be affected but we wouldn’t look at that in isolation of the forestry activity,” he said.

He thinks the provincial process for Prosperity did look at issues such as bears, along with other key values like water qualify and fish habitat.

“I think we did [look at grazing and bears] and our conclusions are simply different than [the federal’s]. That’s the bottom line coming out of that one.”

He did highlight some differences in the way the provincial and federal processes work out.

“They do have a different mandate than we do. We look at not only environmental affects, we look at health, social, heritage, economic. There are some differences in what we look at.”

He did counter the claim that there is no clear policy or guideline in the provincial process.

“Our process, although the legislation gives us lots of flexibility, some people have criticized that, but I think if you look at the procedures and policies we follow when we conduct an [environmental assessment], it’s fairly robust. You can’t just look at our act and come to a conclusion, I think you need to actually look at what we’re doing.”

The report will play a role in how the EAO improves itself in the future, as does all reports and self-reflection by the EAO itself.

“Like the auditor general’s report we’re really taking to heart and looking at what we need to do there.

“We have a culture and practice of continuous improvement anyway so whenever we finish a project we have a debriefing and we talk about what worked well and what didn’t,” he said. “We’ll do the same with this report … . If we have to revise what we’re doing we’ll certainly do that.”

When contacted about the report, Brian Battison, vice-president of corporate affairs for Taseko, characterized the outcome in the provincial and federal assessments as “very similar.” Where the differences lie, he says, is in what the governments did with the information.

“The provincial government says yes, there’s a significant adverse effect associated with the loss of the lake but it’s justified because we were building a new lake and the value and benefit that it delivered to B.C. which was in the public interest,” he said.

“They (federal government) were not able to justify the granting of authorizations. They came to a different decision but the environmental assessments came to similar conclusions; however, they decided it was not justified as proposed.”

The report compares various aspects of the two assessments.

For example, the provincial EAO said that the project would not have “significant adverse effects on wildlife.”

While the federal report concluded, “in combination with reasonably foreseeable future forestry activities in the area would be likely to result in high magnitude, long-term effects on the South Chilcotin grizzly bear population.”

For the Xeni Gwet’in trapline the provincial report indicated no adverse effects on the right to hunt and trap, while the federal panel concluded the project would not result in significant adverse effect on trapping in the region but would cause a significant adverse effect on the Xeni Gwet’in /Sonny Lulua trapline affected by the mine site footprint, the NWI report says.

— With files from Cameron Orr

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

FILE - In this April 19, 2021, file photo, Keidy Ventura, 17, receives her first dose of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine in West New York, N.J. States across the country are dramatically scaling back their COVID-19 vaccine orders as interest in the shots wanes, putting the goal of herd immunity further out of reach. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)
5 more deaths, 131 new cases of COVID-19 in Interior Health over the weekend

Those 18-years and older in high-transmission neighbourhoods can register for the vaccine

(File photo)
High-visibility arrest in Williams Lake nets BB gun, mistaken for assault rifle

RCMP thought the man was carrying an M16 assault-style rifle

LETTER: Improvements needed at Scout Island

The City can do better managing their responsibilities

More than 14,800 COVID-19 vaccines have been administered at clinics in Williams Lake, Alexis Creek, Big Lake, Horsefly, West Chilcotin, 100 Mile House and Clinton as of Friday, May 7. (Monica Lamb-Yorski photo - Williams Lake Tribune)
6,000-plus people vaccinated for COVID-19 in Williams Lake, and in 100 Mile House

Interior Health Authority provide the numbers up to May 7, 2021

As a former reporter and editor at the Tribune, Diana French carries on sharing her ideas through her weekly column. (Photo submitted)
FRENCH CONNECTION: Reasonable decision making can go a long way

We’re all at fault, but today I’ll pick on politicians

A bullet hole is seen in the windshield of an RCMP vehicle approximately 4 km from Vancouver International Airport after a one person was killed during a shooting outside the international departures terminal at the airport, in Richmond, B.C., Sunday, May 9, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Homicide team IDs man in fatal YVR shooting as police grapple with spate of gang violence

Man, 20, charged in separate fatal shooting Burnaby over the weekend

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

The B.C. legislature went from 85 seats to 87 before the 2017 election, causing a reorganization with curved rows and new desks squeezed in at the back. The next electoral boundary review could see another six seats added. (Black Press files)
B.C. election law could add six seats, remove rural protection

North, Kootenays could lose seats as cities gain more

The Independent Investigations Office of B.C. is investigating the shooting of an Indigenous woman in the Ucluelet First Nation community of Hitacu. (Black Press Media file photo)
B.C. First Nation wants ‘massive change’ after its 3rd police shooting in less than a year

Nuu-chah-nulth woman recovering from gunshot wounds in weekend incident near Ucluelet

Nurse Gurinder Rai, left, administers the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine to Maria Yule at a Fraser Health drive-thru vaccination site, in Coquitlam, B.C., on Wednesday, May 5, 2021. The site is open for vaccinations 11 hours per day to those who have pre-booked an appointment. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
COVID vaccine bookings to open for adults 40+, or 18+ in hotspots, across B.C.

Only people who have registered will get their alert to book

Dr. Victoria Lee, CEO of Fraser Health, hosts an update on efforts to contain B.C.’s COVID-19 transmission in Surrey and the Fraser Valley and protect hospitals in the Lower Mainland, May 6, 2021. (B.C. government video)
B.C.’s COVID-19 infection rate slowing, 20 more people die

Deaths include two people in their 40s, two in their 50s

The Canadian Forces Snowbirds are in the Comox Valley for their annual spring training. Photo by Erin Haluschak
Suspected bird strike on Snowbirds plane during training in B.C.

Pilot followed protocols and landed the aircraft on the ground without any problems

BCIT. (Wikimedia Commons)
BCIT apologizes after employee’s ‘offensive and hurtful’ email leaked to Métis Nation

BCIT says employee’s conduct has been investigated and addressed

Most Read