Scientist’s comments not supported by research

Why isn’t research on suspended sediment being recognized by Lynn Anglin and Imperial Metals?


With regards to the Williams Lake Tribune article submitted by Lynn Anglin of Imperial Metals dated May 10 titled “Progress Made on Remediation at Mount Polley.”

I find that her comment “The tailings in Quesnel Lake, which is a very deep lake, are sitting at depths of greater than 100 metres and there is no evidence that they are re-suspending” is not supported by other research undertaken on Quesnel Lake as a result of the disaster that occurred in 2014.

The UNBC research by Dr. Ellen Petticrew and Dr. Phil Owens and other researchers from various universities finds that the resuspension of the tailings may be occurring.

In a related communication that I recently received from the UNBC research team the following was stated:

“Results of post-spill water column monitoring indicate elevated turbidities in the bottom waters of the West Basin in the fall and winter, when the lake circulation is most active.

This was observed in fall 2015, 2016, and 2017 with decreasing intensity each year.

Suspended sediment delivered to the Quesnel River from the lake exhibits copper levels exceeding both local background sediment concentrations (60-100 mg/kg) and the probable effects level for aquatic organisms (197 mg/kg) in mid-October 2014 through to late-May 2015, again from November 2015 through to mid-May 2016 and in January of 2017.

The timing of these high river sediment copper concentrations corresponds with the elevated turbidity in the West Basin.

These observations suggest the copper-elevated suspended sediment in the Quesnel River is coming from the bottom waters of the West Basin.

The original source of these sediments could be natural or mine-related material, or a combination of both. Research is continuing to determine the source of this sediment.”

Further to this I understand that Lynn Anglin and other Imperial Metals staff have been present for presentations by UNBC and other universities that discuss the summary of West Basin Turbidity and Quesnel River Suspended Sediment Copper Concentrations provided above by UNBC.

I and many of your readers would be pleased to know why this research on suspended sediment is not being recognized by Lynn Anglin and Imperial Metals in her May 10 article.

Richard Holmes

Likely, BC

Just Posted

Evacuation alert boundaries reduced for communities north of Quesnel

Communities west of the Fraser River remain on alert, including Nazko, Baker Creek and Blackwater.

Rebuild of fire-damaged Lakeview mill aiming for full-production by Feb. 2019

The company said it hopes to resume full production by February 2019.

Update on wildfires in the Cariboo, Aug. 14

Progress made on fires of note in the region

Beaulne appointed vice-principal of Lake City Secondary School

School District 27 has announced Kristina Beaulne has been appointed vice-principal of LCSS

Evacuation alert lifted for 57 properties in Houseman Road area

The Houseman wildfire is now considered being held and is 100 per cent contained

Average Canadian family spends 43% of income on taxes: study

Fraser Institute’s consumer report shows taxes accounting for larger chunk of income each year

RCMP to search for body after man drowns in B.C.’s Buntzen Lake

Officers and fire crews responded but the man from the Lower Mainland is believed to have drowned.

Police chiefs call for stricter controls on pill presses to fight opioids

Canada’s police chiefs are urging Ottawa to beef up its fight against the opioid scourge by closely vetting people who import pill presses

Hot, dry conditions forces drought rating to highest level on Vancouver Island

The province says Vancouver Island is under Stage 4 drought conditions

Victoria police say explicit calls continue to target women

Over 50 reports of unwanted, sexually explicit calls have come in

‘It’s like a party in your mouth’

B.C. creator’s Milkshake Burger makes its debut at the PNE

Get involved in the Great Canadian Bumble Bee Count

Environmental organization develops app to help with the nationwide count

Pesticides linked to bee deaths will be phased out in Canada, sources say

Neonicotinoids, or neonics, are a class of pesticides used by farmers and hobby gardeners alike

Most Read